I like the old-tyme shaving creams and aftershaves: from Italy's Prorasso line to good ole' Walgreen's Aqua Velva & Pinaud's Clubman. I ordered Ogalla's Bay Rum Bonanza Pack from the interwebz. For twenty bucks, you get 5 different formulas of Bay Rum--one, two ounce cologne and four, two ounce aftershave formulas. All excellent and a nice way to sample what you like best. That's probably close to two months worth of aftershave if you're shaving 5x per week. High quality, great deal!
which isn't a Bay Rum but kinda cool and old fashiony?
Do you consider classic Old Spice as a Bay Rum or is it too floral? One thing I know, women of a certain age love it.
I have Lilac Vegetal and am not a fan. In fact, the bottle I have is probably 5+ years old. Not an Old Spice guy, either. Now if I can land me some Paco Rabbane after shave, I'll bust out my Capezios, Parachute Pants and Member's Only jacket and rock 'da house!